Canada Rejects Criticism

Posted: June 1, 2014 in Prose
Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,
National Post, Dec 20, 2012

Canada rejects UN human rights criticism detailed in Amnesty International

Allison Cross | December 19, 2012 | Last Updated: Dec 20, 2013 9:27 AM ET
More from Allison Cross | @AllisonCross

Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence announces the beginning of a hunger strike while on Parliament HIll in Ottawa, on Dec. 10.

Jean Levac / Postmedia NewsAttawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence announces the beginning of a hunger strike while on Parliament HIll in Ottawa, on Dec. 1



Canada is again rejecting criticism of its human rights record after the release of a report that highlights the longstanding issues facing Aboriginal peoples.

Three mandatory United Nations reviews conducted in 2012 all found “very serious human rights challenges facing Indigenous peoples” in Canada, says an Amnesty International report released Wednesday.

“By every measure, be it respect for treaty and land rights, levels of poverty, average life spans, violence against women and girls, dramatically disproportionate levels of arrest and incarceration or access to government services such as housing, health care, education, water and child protection, Indigenous peoples across Canada continue to face a grave human rights crisis,” the report says.

A spokesman for Foreign Affairs minister John Baird said it was odd the UN was using its resources to evaluate Canada.

“We find it strange that the United Nations Special Rapporteurs are devoting their scarce resources to countries like Canada, instead of countries like Iran and Syria where citizens do not enjoy rights and are subject to serious human rights violations at the hands of those regimes,” Rick Roth said.

“Our government has a clear objective to focus on freedom, democracy, human rights and the rule of law around the world. We take strong, principled positions in our dealings with other nations whether popular or not, and that is what the world can count on from Canada.”

In addition to the rights of Aboriginal peoples, Wednesday’s report says Canada needs improvement in seven other areas: women’s human rights, corporate accountability and trade policy, the rights of refugees and migrants, Canadians subject to human rights violations abroad, economic, social and cultural rights, the shrinking space for advocacy and dissent, and engagement with the multilateral human rights system.

Amnesty International recommends that Canada develop a national action plan to implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

“Concerted action is needed,” Alex Neve, Secretary General of the English branch of Amnesty International Canada, said in a written statement.

“It will take leadership, and long overdue cooperation and coordination among federal, provincial and territorial governments. But it cannot wait any longer. Canadians whose rights are affected need assurance that Canada will meet the country’s international obligations.”

A spokesman for John Duncan, Minister of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development, said they too are anxious to see change.

“While we are making progress, we too are impatient to see more change that will benefit First Nation communities,” Jason MacDonald said.

“For instance, First Nations are calling for discussion on the treaty relationship between the Crown and First Nations. We agree that on this point more work is required. That is one of the reasons we have proposed to the Assembly of First Nations that we explore how best to work together on improving the treaty relationship.”

The federal government has taken concrete action since 2006, MacDonald said, which has included building 30 new schools and 10,000 new homes on reserves, investing money in safe drinking water systems and settling more than 80 outstanding land claims.

The report also chastises the government for its reactions to past visits from UN experts and independent committees, wherein politicians rejected advice and “insulted” those giving it out.

“In all instances, the suggestion was that because Canada’s record is not as bad as that of many countries, Canada’s record should not be internationally scrutinized,” the report says.

In May, a United Nations envoy who specializes in the right to food blasted Canada for failing to deal with the issue of food insecurity — criticism the federal government dismissed.

Critics questioned why envoy Olivier De Schutter bothered to visit a wealthy, democratic nation like Canada, given the number of other countries in the world coping with extreme hunger.

The envoy also highlighted the lack of appropriate food on remote First Nations reserves. Health Minister Leona Aglukkaq called De Schutter’s advice “ill-informed and “patronizing,” referencing the fact that he didn’t visit Canada’s north.

In October, the federal government rejected UN claims that Bill C-10, an omnibus crime bill that included tougher penalties for youth, was too harsh for children. Earlier this month, Canada joined other Western nations in rejecting a UN telecommunications treaty amid concerns it would give governments teeth to control the internet.

National Post



  1. Hadel says:

    Reblogged this on Hadel.


  2. kennymack2 says:

    Only blood and guts brings respect from Politicians and an apathetic public.i.e ‘Wounded Knee’ ,the “Black panthers”


  3. I really get so fed up with politicians’ weasel words.


  4. Weasel words is a very apt description, especially since treaty negotiations with aboriginal people have continued for two hundred and fifty-four years. By negotiations, I mean the government broke the treaties and is still trying to squirm out of them. These actions make me ashamed to be Canadian.


  5. So many forget the injustice’s upon their doorsteps.. Great post Dennis.. I support The Council of Indian Nations ..


  6. Did the UN criticize or was it just presenting facts … such as our child care rating compared to countries rated the highest in child care?


    • Three mandatory United Nations reviews conducted in 2012 all found “very serious human rights challenges facing Indigenous peoples” in Canada, says an Amnesty International report released Wednesday.


  7. demostenes13 says:

    As a non-Canadian I had no idea that these problems even existed there! Thx so much for this post. This issue obviously needs more attention and awareness.


  8. To thank you for being a blogger who inspires me, I nominated you for the Most Inspiring Blogger Award. Check it out at:


  9. Rob McShane says:

    It appears that “Mans inhumanity to man,” knows no boundaries, geographical location or position. First world or third world matters not. I was not aware of these issues in Canada. When will we be able to respect and treat each other with care and consideration? We are all so alike in our differences and all retain an inner essence of light and divinity. So sad that the outer layers become so predominant. Thank you for the advocacy and education. In hope that we can all learn to respect the part of us we all share…and quickly!


  10. Bulrush says:

    Nice work. Harper is an ass and the rest are too.
    Great Spirit


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.